[VINSON & ELKINS LETTERHEAD]
February 10, 2005
United
States Securities and Exchange Commission
450 Fifth Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20549
Attention: | Ms. Lesli L. Sheppard Division of Corporate Finance |
Ladies and Gentlemen:
On behalf of Huntsman Corporation (the "Company"), we enclose four courtesy copies of the Company's Amendment No. 5 ("Amendment No. 5") to its Registration Statement on Form S-1 (the "Registration Statement") that was filed on February 10, 2005, each of which has been marked to show changes from Amendment No. 2 to the Registration Statement filed on January 28, 2005 ("Amendment No. 2"). The Company filed Amendment No. 3 to the Registration Statement on February 8, 2005 ("Amendment No. 2") and Amendment No. 4 to the Registration Statement on February 9, 2005 ("Amendment No. 4") as "exhibits only" filings to transmit certain exhibits to the Registration Statement.
This letter sets forth the responses of the Company to the comments of the staff of the Securities and Exchange Commission (the "Staff") in the comment letter of the Staff dated February 2, 2005. Please note that, to the extent these responses are predicated on factual information, that information has, unless otherwise indicated, been provided by the Company. For your convenience, we have repeated each comment of the Staff exactly as given in the order given and set forth below it the response of the Company. Capitalized terms used in this letter and not defined have the meanings given to them in the Registration Statement.
Fee Table
Dilution, page 35
Management's Discussion and Analysis, page
Restructuring and Plant Closing Costs, page 85
Principal and Selling Stockholders, page 163
Huntsman Holdings, LLC financial statements for the nine-months ended
September 30, 2004 and the year ended December 31, 2003
The Company considers both the gross and net effect on each period's total revenues and operating income for each company to be quantitatively immaterial as demonstrated in the column labeled "Net Effect as a Percentage of Reported Amount" presented below. Accordingly, the
2
Company removed the term "generally" from the revenue recognition accounting policy for HIH disclosed on pages F-151 and F-174 of the revised prospectus included in Amendment No. 5. In addition, the Company has revised its revenue recognition policy and that of AdMat to indicate that title to the product transfers to the customer upon shipment. Please see pages 94 and F-14 of the revised prospectus included in Amendment No. 5.
In addition to the quantitative analysis presented below, the Company has reviewed the errors in light of Staff Accounting Bulletin 99 and believes the following qualitative analysis supports its conclusion that these errors are not material and that a reasonable person would not consider the errors important or view the errors as having significantly altered the total mix of information available. The errors do not mask a change in operating income or other trends nor do they hide a failure to meet analysts' expectations for the Company. The errors do not change a loss into income or vice versa. The errors do not have a significant impact on segment reporting or other portions of the Company that have been identified as playing a significant role in the Company's operations or profitability. The errors have no impact on the Company's compliance with regulatory requirements, debt covenants or other contractual requirements. The errors do not have the effect of increasing management's compensation in any way. Additionally, the errors do not involve concealment of an unlawful transaction.
3
|
Effect at End of Period |
Effect at Date of Change from Equity Method to Consolidation |
Effect at Beginning of Period |
Net Effect |
Total Reported Amount for the Period |
Net Effect as a Percentage of Reported Amount |
||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
(in millions, except percentages) |
|||||||||||||||||
Financial Statements of Huntsman Holdings, LLC |
||||||||||||||||||
Nine months ended September 30, 2004 | ||||||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 39 | N/A | $ | 28 | $ | 11 | $ | 8,358 | 0.1 | % | |||||||
Operating income | $ | 6.6 | N/A | $ | 5.8 | $ | 0.8 | $ | 216.4 | 0.4 | % | |||||||
Nine months ended September 30, 2003 |
||||||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 32 | $ | 23 | (1) | $ | 2 | $ | 7 | $ | 4,711 | 0.1 | % | |||||
Operating income | $ | 6.5 | $ | 3.0 | (1) | $ | 0.6 | $ | 2.9 | $ | 91.9 | 3.2 | % | |||||
Year ended December 31, 2003 |
||||||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 28 | $ | 23 | (1) | $ | 2 | $ | 3 | $ | 7,081 | 0.0 | % | |||||
Operating income | $ | 5.8 | $ | 3.0 | (1) | $ | 0.6 | $ | 2.2 | $ | 176.5 | 1.2 | % | |||||
Year ended December 31, 2002 |
||||||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 2 | N/A | $ | 2 | $ | | $ | 2,661 | 0.0 | % | |||||||
Operating income | $ | 0.6 | N/A | $ | 0.5 | $ | 0.1 | $ | 66.3 | 0.2 | % | |||||||
Year ended December 31, 2001 |
||||||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 2 | N/A | $ | 2 | $ | | $ | 2,757 | 0.0 | % | |||||||
Operating loss | $ | 0.5 | N/A | $ | 0.5 | $ | | $ | (709.4 | ) | 0.0 | % |
In considering the materiality of the error quantified above for the nine months ended September 30, 2003, the Company has also considered the effect of the improper cut-off at the date of change in accounting for its investment in HIH from the equity method to consolidation (May 1, 2003) on the reported results of equity in unconsolidated subsidiaries. This effect, for the nine months ended September 30, 2003, related to the error in revenue recognition, would be an increase of $0.7 million or 1.8% of the reported equity in losses of unconsolidated subsidiaries of $38.2 million.
4
|
As Reported |
Adjustments to Correct |
As if Corrected |
Adjustments as a % of Reported Balance |
|||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
(in millions, except percentages) |
||||||||
Financial Statements of Huntsman Holdings, LLC (alternative analysis) |
|||||||||
Nine Months Ended September 30, 2004 | |||||||||
Revenues | 8,357.7 | (11.0 | ) | 8,346.7 | -0.1 | % | |||
Operating Income | 216.4 | (0.8 | ) | 215.6 | -0.4 | % | |||
Equity in losses of unconsolidated subsidiaries | 3.0 | | 3.0 | 0.0 | % | ||||
Net Loss(1) | (226.5 | ) | (0.8 | ) | (227.3 | ) | 0.4 | % | |
Nine Months Ended September 30, 2003 |
|||||||||
Revenues | 4,711.1 | (7.0 | ) | 4,704.1 | -0.1 | % | |||
Operating Income | 91.9 | (2.9 | ) | 89.0 | -3.2 | % | |||
Equity in losses of unconsolidated subsidiaries | (38.2 | ) | (0.7 | ) | (38.9 | ) | 1.8 | % | |
Net Loss(1) | (214.2 | ) | (3.6 | ) | (217.8 | ) | 1.7 | % | |
Year Ended December 31, 2003 |
|||||||||
Revenues | 7,080.9 | (3.0 | ) | 7,077.9 | 0.0 | % | |||
Operating Income | 176.5 | (2.2 | ) | 174.3 | -1.2 | % | |||
Equity in losses of unconsolidated subsidiaries | (37.5 | ) | (0.7 | ) | (38.2 | ) | 1.9 | % | |
Net Loss(1) | (319.8 | ) | (2.9 | ) | (322.7 | ) | 0.9 | % | |
Year Ended December 31, 2002 |
|||||||||
Revenues | 2,661.0 | | 2,661.0 | 0.0 | % | ||||
Operating Income | 66.3 | (0.1 | ) | 66.2 | -0.2 | % | |||
Equity in losses of unconsolidated subsidiaries | (31.4 | ) | 0.4 | (31.0 | ) | -1.3 | % | ||
Net Loss(2) | (22.2 | ) | 0.3 | (21.9 | ) | -1.4 | % |
5
|
Effect at End of Period |
Effect at Beginning of Period |
Net Effect |
Total Reported Amount for the Period |
Net Effect as a Percentage of Reported Amount |
||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
(in millions, except percentages) |
||||||||||||||
Financial Statements of Huntsman Advanced Materials LLC |
|||||||||||||||
Six months ended December 31, 2003 | |||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 1 | $ | 1 | $ | | $ | 518 | 0.0 | % | |||||
Operating income | $ | 0.3 | $ | 0.0 | $ | 0.3 | $ | 11.3 | 2.7 | % | |||||
Six months ended June 30, 2003 |
|||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 1 | (2) | $ | 1 | (2) | $ | | $ | 532 | 0.0 | % | |||
Operating loss | $ | 0.3 | (2) | $ | 0.3 | (2) | $ | | $ | (53.0 | ) | 0.0 | % | ||
Year ended December 31, 2002 |
|||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 1 | (2) | $ | 1 | (2) | $ | | $ | 949 | 0.0 | % | |||
Operating loss | $ | 0.3 | (2) | $ | 0.3 | (2) | $ | | $ | (73.0 | ) | 0.0 | % | ||
Year ended December 31, 2001 |
|||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 1 | (2) | $ | 1 | (2) | $ | | $ | 949 | 0.0 | % | |||
Operating loss | $ | 0.3 | (2) | $ | 0.3 | (2) | $ | | $ | (34.0 | ) | 0.0 | % |
6
|
Effect at End of Period |
Effect at Beginning of Period |
Net Effect |
Total Reported Amount for the Period |
Net Effect as a Percentage of Reported Amount |
||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
(in millions, except percentages) |
||||||||||||||
Financial Statements of Huntsman International Holdings LLC |
|||||||||||||||
Three months ended March 31, 2003 | |||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 17 | $ | 17 | $ | | $ | 1,298 | 0.0 | % | |||||
Operating income | $ | 3.7 | $ | 3.6 | $ | 0.1 | $ | 17.5 | 0.6 | % | |||||
Three months ended March 31, 2002 |
|||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 18 | $ | 17 | $ | 1 | $ | 998 | 0.1 | % | |||||
Operating income | $ | 4.2 | $ | 4.3 | $ | (0.1 | ) | $ | 27.9 | -0.4 | % | ||||
Year ended December 31, 2002 |
|||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 17 | $ | 18 | $ | (1 | ) | $ | 4,518 | 0.0 | % | ||||
Operating income | $ | 3.6 | $ | 4.5 | $ | (0.9 | ) | $ | 228.1 | -0.4 | % | ||||
Year ended December 31, 2001 |
|||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 18 | $ | 18 | $ | | $ | 4,575 | 0.0 | % | |||||
Operating income | $ | 4.5 | $ | 4.5 | $ | | $ | 173.1 | 0.0 | % | |||||
Year ended December 31, 2000 |
|||||||||||||||
Total revenues | $ | 18 | $ | 19 | $ | (1 | ) | $ | 4,448 | 0.0 | % | ||||
Operating income | $ | 4.5 | $ | 4.9 | $ | (0.4 | ) | $ | 423.7 | -0.1 | % |
7
The Company's asbestos exposure cases are typically brought by many individuals, often independent contractors, seeking damages for asbestos exposure claims against the numerous owners of facilities at which any of the plaintiffs worked over periods of many years. The complaints in these cases do not state the amount of damages being sought. Because of the nature of these cases, it is normally not possible for any particular defendant to be able to determine exactly what, if any, damages are being alleged against it by any particular plaintiff. We divide these cases into two categoriesthose with respect to which we are fully indemnified and those with respect to which we are not indemnified.
Indemnified Cases
With respect to all of the Company's pending asbestos exposure claims (other than those discussed below in "Unindemnified Cases"), the Company is protected by the former owner of Texaco Chemical Corporation ("TCC"), which the Company acquired in 1994. Under the Company's agreement pursuant to which it purchased TCC, which was a subsidiary of ChevronTexaco, the predecessor owner, ChevronTexaco, agreed to retain liabilities for asbestos claims that arose prior to the Company's ownership and to indemnify it for those claims. As disclosed, this retention of liability and indemnity is not subject to a cap or limited duration. When the Company receives service of such a claim, it promptly tenders the case to the predecessor, without conducting any discovery. In the Company's experience, its indemnitor has always accepted defense of the tendered cases, ending the Company's involvement in such cases other than responding to limited informational requests from the indemnitor.
The Company has included information concerning the cases tendered to ChevronTexaco which remain pending as of the end of each of the periods presented. However, the Company does not have information upon which it can estimate the gross probable liability for such cases because it does not have access to the terms on which ChevronTexaco has resolved these cases in past periods, and does not have information concerning where or how the alleged injuries occurred or
8
what injuries each plaintiff claims with respect to pending cases. Therefore the Company has not included an accrual for the gross liability associated with these cases.
For future reporting periods, the Company undertakes to actively seek additional information from Chevron Texaco that will allow it to calculate an estimate of its gross liability with respect to the tendered asbestos claims. The Company commits to undertake a rigorous analysis of the potential gross liability associated with these cases on an ongoing basis based upon all information available to it, including additional information it can obtain from ChevronTexaco, for purposes of determining appropriate accruals and disclosure regarding these cases.
Unindemnified Cases
With respect to the cases that are not covered by indemnity, the Company has revised the disclosure to clarify that its stated expenditures for these cases in the last three years were on a gross rather than net basis. The Company's practice has been to accrue reserves for these cases when the amount of loss can be reasonably estimated. At September 30, 2004, and December 31, 2003, 2002 and 2001, the Company's accrued reserves for these cases was $1.1 million, $1.3 million, $0 and $0, respectively. Given the nature of these cases, the Company cannot reasonably estimate the amount of loss related to unasserted claims and accordingly has not provided for such claims in its reserves.
With respect to the comment of the Staff to include in the roll forward of lawsuits an amount or range of amounts claimed for each period presented, please note that none of such claims contains the amount of damages being sought. Accordingly, the Company has not included such information in the revised prospectus.
Exhibit 5.1Draft Legal Opinion
9
10
If you have any questions with respect to the foregoing, please call the undersigned at (713) 758-3278, Jeff Floyd at (713) 758-2194 or David Stone at (713) 758-2236.
Very truly yours, | |||
Vinson & Elkins L.L.P. |
|||
By: |
/s/ W. CREIGHTON SMITH W. Creighton Smith |
Enclosures
11